Wednesday, October 22, 2008

I am India - A functioning anarchy

As I open the news websites today for India , I'm greeted with these three top news items:

1) India's first mission to the moon
2) Raj Thackrey's arrest over extreme regionalism shown by his political party
3) Gay rights and legalization of homosexuality

Three totally unrelated events somehow all intertwined in the amazing web that is INDIA. As I get kicked from one country to another for work, I'm often asked the same questions again and again and i thought maybe its time to post something about it and point everyone to the blog.(Wink ;) gets more people reading it too). The most often asked question -"What do you say xyz in Indian", can actually raise and answer all questions about India in my mind. When I'm asked this question I often go into a big monologue description of India so that the poor questioner wishes he never had asked the question. But honestly the answer has to be in this way for the person to get a complete context of the question.

What follows herein is as much of a personal debate as it is an opinion

Here's my typical answer : Well i can't tell you what xyz is called in Indian cause there is no such language called Indian. I however can tell what xyz is called in any of the 25 major languages in India.(Please don't kill me, the actual number of major languages and their classification is varied from different sources,so I'm taking a round number here) To understand India better think of Europe as a single country. The Danes are as different from the Spanish as are the British from the Poles. This is India in a nutshell. We speak different languages from one state to another,wear different clothes, eat completely different food (yeah almost everything is spicy to the bland European palate...thank you very much) and have different social setups and customs . Not all over India is beef banned (its even a delicacy in south and east India) as much as not everyone in India is doing yoga. Yes, religions and castes are very much prevalent and their effects are very noticeable. But to understand it ,you need to probably read a contemporary book (readers please suggest a good book which discusses religion and caste system in Modern India) about it. And we still stand United in our diversity.

Yes we are the world's largest democracy but its a joke. The rich don't care as no one can touch them, The poor are too hungry to worry about democracy when they have stomachs to feed(and hence the votes are bought for as low as a promised day's meal) and the most populated "educated,sensitive and highly opinionated"middle class (myself included of course) are too concerned about dirtying their hands in the muck that is Indian politics. Thus it is but natural that the leaders are representative of such a society-the politicians aka the Indian mafia.

Yes we are a trillion dollar GDP economy growing at 8-9% per annum. We have the highest population of educated ,English speaking Under 30 population in the world. We have the highest number of billionaires in Asia and quite a few businesses making it into the Forbes 500 list. Business CEO's across the globe swear by the Indian IT companies & in fact many of the global CEO's are Indians.

Yes we do not have the infrastructure to sustain the growth and need 300 billion dollars of immediate investment in infrastructure just to hold all of this growth together let alone fuel it.
Yes we have a free and powerful press and media and yes my blog can be blocked if Raj Thackrey takes offence to it.

So it is this contrasting views of India that is again shown in the top 3 news items of the day. We are proving our scientific and economic might by sending a mission to the moon and showing we are in touch with modern society and its sensibilities by for the first time taking serious steps in regards to gay rights and homosexuality .However we also take a step back by showing extreme regionalism. Raj Thackeray is the political leader who is trying to make Maharashtra for Maharashtrians ONLY.

But we push on. There's a great confidence in today's India and its young minds. We will make a difference, we will make the politicians accountable, we will push Indian industries to greater heights,we will clean up the system and we will build our infrastructure and we will make sure no child goes hungry. And remember when a billion people say this you better not be in the way.

This my dear friends is the contrast that is India.If you thought you could describe it in one sentence then you got another thing coming. But if we think again, it IS possible to describe India in one sentence. And that is to rewrite the quote of my dear friend Neelabh :

WE are - I am -India -the world's only functioning anarchy.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

We are struggling as a country, struggling to keep up with the rest of world while keeping our unique identity intact.

This struggle is causing friction. And its now time to see where it goes...

Nikhil Narayanan said...

Dude,
You need to come back.
Sheri aavula avide ;)

-Nikhil

Nikhil Narayanan said...

Don't get senti, come back -I meant
-Nikhil

PS:seems what I wrote was vague :D

Resly Mathews said...

Nice blog...I share a very similiar p.o.v
-Resly

Vivek Menon said...

@ Rashi - We all wait with baited breaths i guess..

@Nikhil - Swades redux huh..who knows your wish might come true

@Resly-Hey buddy are the Resly i know..glad to see you here man.Hows things going and are you blogging??

Varun said...

An apt description of the current goings on in the country,with a nice dry humor touch.well written.

1 disagreement though,about raj thackrey.I despise his people for their actions,but not his ideology,and the sentence you used
"Raj Thackeray is the political leader who is trying to make Maharashtra for Maharashtrians ONLY."
is completely factually and figuratively incorrect.But that is a debate for any day but this :)

Anonymous said...

First of all! a very good read. Just keep it up!
Though It hurts when I read anything like joke on Indian democracy but undoubtedly it is a bitter truth.
And certainly one question strike my mind. Do we need another Gandhi? or it will be again a disrespect of a person named Gandhi?

DestinyFavChild said...

Pretty much my line of thought...the biggest problem with us Indians is that we have too much free time...so we go on creating havoc in this free time...from leaders who wud rather conspire than work for greater common good...philosophers who would rather preach than practice...we are a nation of yappy talkers and few doers...the basic reason why we have so much disparity...

Anonymous said...

India- A functioning Anarchy.

Why do you hate the Idea of Anarchy?

Ever heard of the ideas of Miniarchy, and Anarcho-capitalism?

What about Ayn Rand, Murray Rothbard Bastiat, John Locke, Hayek, Ludwig Von Mises etc?

Would like you to have a look here

EveryDay Anarchy

Miniarchy, or capitalistic anarchy will surely be much better than the Governmental Mafia raj india and even every other country in this world suffers!

Thomas said...

Hmm and i thought India was all about yoga, fakirs and turbans. There goes that impression...

Vivek, thanks for a well written view into part of the current state of affairs in India. Always interesting to hear what is on the agenda in other parts of the world.

pooja said...

hey vivek..ur blog is def. a good read, and as far as this post is concerned - i agree with you on all the "bitter"facts u hav quoted...(but then again which country's perfect...wud love if u write something on a more positive note as well).
What i like the most is how you picked up these 3 headlines and showed a contrast , v nice indeed!

Grapes said...

I enjoy reading your blog but I especially enjoy what I've learned from it. I have not been to India but hope to someday and especially sooner rather than later.

"But we push on. There's a great confidence in today's India and its young minds." Confidence is great, young minds are even better and never be scared of change. Cheers from America!

Vivek Menon said...

@Varun: Well I would be glad to have a discussion with you about Raj Thackrey and his brand of politics..Always open to correcting myself if proved otherwise..

@Zazu: Well If you are meaning Rahul Gandhi(as might be the case reading your blog),you might be right.As it is surely the time for young blood. I believe the younger generation of politicians (be it Rahul Gandhi,Sachin Pilot, Jyotiraditya Scindia,Milind Deora,Mavendra Singh,Rajeev Gowda,Omar Abdullah etc) are all "qualified" to lead this country into a new path...But will the family that has let them into politics drag them into the same family political stagnation?? Have they made an impact as MPs?? And what about the young guns without political lineage?? Can a Young leader emerge from the common masses (Remember Yuva from Mani Rathnam)..also look at the beaurocrats of today.(eg What Vivek Kulkarni did for IT and BioTech in Karnataka) Will they hold the politicians more accountable and make actual imlementation of plans a reality in India.
This remains to be seen...

@ Diva - I do not hate the word anarchy and I meant it more as a description for all the contrasts that India puts forth to any outside that they might see it only as anarchy...The key word for me was Functioning.
Thanks for the read. It was really interesting and also got me knowing more about Misesian Austrian school of economics and their prediction of the economic crisis and Greenspan's own contradictions with Objectivism and his job.

@ Thomas- Let me point out to my readers, this is classic Danish sarcassm at work. He ofcourse knows better and probably knows more about Gandhi than me.Hehehe

@Pooja - I was in a very patriotic mood when i wrote this one. Unfortunately it seems your intepretation has not been the same as mine. But then so is the liberty of the reader right. Why else would we pick up a book instead of watching the Movie?

@Grapes - Well you should visit sometime soon ,Lindsay. Remember to give me a buzz if you do. And hope your vote is not wasted this time around.

Unknown said...

Nice one there!!!

First visit to your blog.. pretty interesting.


Keep posting.


Shradha

www.dark-gal.blogspot.com